Grizzlies Invade Polar BearTurf

By Michael D. Lemonick Saturday, Feb. 27, 2010

From left: Paul Souders / Corbis; Wayne R Bilenduke / Getty

If you want to see polar bears up close, the place to go is Churchill, Manitoba, on the western shore of Hudson Bay. When the ice breaks up in summer, it’s here that the bears come ashore by the hundreds to wait for the autumn re-freeze. So it’s here that tourists and scientists come as well, to gawk at and study the huge white predators. Just south of Churchill, the Canadian government recently created Wapusk National Park (wapusk means “white bear” in the indigenous Cree language), to protect the area where pregnant females dig their dens.

But in recent years, another large predator, not quite as big as the polar bear but equally fierce, has been spotted in Wapusk. Although hunters eradicated them from Manitoba more than a 100 years ago, grizzly bears are trickling back and setting the stage for what could be a fascinating natural ecological experiment.

If a reshuffling of grizzly and polar bear populations is nigh, it’s not clear where the new lines will be drawn, says Robert Rockwell, a biologist with the American Museum of Natural History in New York City and the co-author of a new paper in the journal The Canadian Field-Naturalist documenting a spate of recent grizzly sightings. Before 1996, there had been no evidence of grizzlies in the national park, but between 1996 and 2009, Rockwell says there were nine confirmed sightings, plus three more in 2009.

Some experts have suggested the grizzlies might not even stick around long enough to face off with polar bears, says Rockwell, but he isn’t buying that. The 4,000-plus-sq.-mi. park where hunting is banned is what Rockwell calls a “food Mecca” for grizzlies. Wapusk is home to some 7,000 caribou, an equal number of moose, and untold numbers of rabbits, fish, geese and other creatures. When Rockwell and his team ask the real experts — the Cree elders whose ancestors have lived here for generations — they say, “Why would a bear that’s found a huge food source go someplace else?” according to Rockwell.

Paradoxically, the intrusion of another top predator could in some ways make life easier for the white bears, says Rockwell. “Polar bears will eat anything they can get their grubby little mouths around,” he says. “They’ll take flightless geese, seals silly enough to get caught on shore when the tide goes out, and caribou and moose calves. But they can’t run fast enough to bring down adult moose or caribou.” Grizzlies can and do — but the catch is, as soon as a grizzly knocks one down, the polar bears will smell it. “An adult male grizzly might weigh 600 lbs. An adult polar bear is more like 1,500 lbs. Grizzlies aren’t stupid,” says Rockwell.

That same instinct for self-preservation will probably mean there won’t be many outright fights of any kind between the two species. “If they hadn’t evolved behavioral mechanisms to reduce unnecessary aggression, they would be extinct” he says, and in fact, “in 41 years in the field, where I sometimes see 200 bears in a day, I’ve seen exactly one aggressive encounter.”

A more likely scenario is that grizzlies would snatch polar-bear cubs as they emerge from their winter dens, or vice versa, says Rockwell. Most intriguing of all is the possibility that the two species might interbreed. “These guys only split off evolutionarily about 150,000 years ago, so hybrids are viable,” he says. That’s no speculation: DNA analysis has proven that a bear shot in 2006 in Canada’s Northwest Territories was part grizzly, part polar bear; the names “grolar bear” and “pizzly” have been floated in reference to it. (The hunter who killed the animal was spared a fine because the local laws against hunting bear apply only to grizzlies). “I think it will be a rare event,” says Rockwell.

The reason for the potential habitat overlap is two-fold: grizzlies seem to be expanding their range east and south from the Rockies, mostly as a result of their growing population, says Rockwell. Polar bears, meanwhile, are spending more time on land, as global warming causes ice to break up earlier and refreeze later in the year. And that means that while encounters of all kinds between these huge bears might be rare today, they could become increasingly common.

Read more:,8599,1968441,00.html?cnn=yes&hpt=T2#ixzz0gwSZaNsH


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: